This case has been cited 3 times or more.
|
2008-07-31 |
NACHURA, J. |
||||
| After acquiring the property, respondent spouses continued to plant sugarcane on the land. Sometime in March 1982, after respondent Jesus Martir harvested the sugarcane he had planted on Lot No. 1318-C, defendant below Roberto Abadiano (son of Ramon) allegedly entered the property and cultivated the remaining stalks of sugarcane and refused to vacate despite demands to do so. The following year, defendants Roberto Abadiano, Faustino Montaño, and Quirico Mandaguit again harvested the sugarcane on Lot No. 1318-C.[16] Further, the defendants also entered the property and harvested the sugarcane on Lot No. 1318-B,[17] which by then had been acquired by Lolita B. Martir from her adoptive father, Amando Bañares.[18] | |||||
|
2008-07-31 |
NACHURA, J. |
||||
| On the other hand, respondent spouses alleged that, prior to the issuance of TCT No. T-31862, Ramon Abadiano, for himself and on behalf of David Abadiano, had already sold their rights and interests over Lot No. 1318-C [11] to Victor Garde. The sale was allegedly evidenced by a document of sale (Compra Y Venta ) dated June 3, 1922 and acknowledged before Notary Public Jose Peralta and bearing notarial inscription "Doc. No. 64, Pag. No. 60, Book No. III, series of 1922." The sale was allegedly affirmed by David Abadiano in a document dated September 30, 1939.[12] | |||||
|
2008-07-31 |
NACHURA, J. |
||||
| After acquiring the property, respondent spouses continued to plant sugarcane on the land. Sometime in March 1982, after respondent Jesus Martir harvested the sugarcane he had planted on Lot No. 1318-C, defendant below Roberto Abadiano (son of Ramon) allegedly entered the property and cultivated the remaining stalks of sugarcane and refused to vacate despite demands to do so. The following year, defendants Roberto Abadiano, Faustino Montaño, and Quirico Mandaguit again harvested the sugarcane on Lot No. 1318-C.[16] Further, the defendants also entered the property and harvested the sugarcane on Lot No. 1318-B,[17] which by then had been acquired by Lolita B. Martir from her adoptive father, Amando Bañares.[18] | |||||